A roof decision should start with condition and scope. Understand the questions that help distinguish a focused repair from a broader replacement.
Look at the pattern, not just the symptom
A localized defect may support a focused repair, while repeated leaks or broad deterioration can point toward a different approach. The age of the roof is useful context, but it is not a diagnosis.
Ask what the assessment can establish now and what may remain concealed until materials are removed.
Compare complete next steps
Discuss the expected scope of a repair, its limitations and the condition of surrounding materials. For replacement, ask how decking, flashing, ventilation and drainage will be treated.
Document the assumptions behind each option. That makes it easier to compare proposals and decide when further investigation is appropriate.